Unprompted

Operated by Skald Studio, which sells AI visibility work. No placement on this chart is for sale.

AI Image Generators · measured 2026-11-16 · reading 2026-11-17

Check the answers behind the chart.

Read the original AI answers behind each brand mention. Each question is scheduled for 5 attempts per assistant. Errors and refusals are shown but excluded from mention percentages.

Questions in reading

15

The question list for this reading.

Answers

450

Of 450 attempts in the full reading, before filters.

Errors or refusals

0

Excluded from brand mention percentages.

Answer coverage by assistant

The share of recorded attempts that produced an answer, before filters.

ChatGPT75/75
Claude75/75
Claude Code (local)75/75
Codex (local)75/75
Gemini75/75
Perplexity75/75

Recorded answers

Each line lists the brands found in one answer.

Choose a question to load its original answers and recorded source links. Sources may be citations or search results; a link alone does not show which brand it supports.

q01

What is the best AI image generator? #

Named first most often: Midjourney (15 of 30 answers with these filters).

30 recorded attempts with these filters.

Read full answers to this question

ChatGPT 5 recorded answers
DALL-E · Midjourney · Ideogram · Adobe Firefly
DALL-E · Midjourney · Ideogram · Adobe Firefly
Midjourney · Ideogram · Adobe Firefly
DALL-E · Midjourney · Imagen · Adobe Firefly
DALL-E · Midjourney · Ideogram
Claude 5 recorded answers
Imagen · Midjourney · Ideogram · Adobe Firefly · Recraft · Flux · Stable Diffusion
Imagen · Midjourney · Ideogram · Adobe Firefly
Midjourney · Ideogram · Recraft · Adobe Firefly · Flux
Imagen · Midjourney · Ideogram · Recraft · Adobe Firefly · Flux
Imagen · Midjourney · Adobe Firefly · Ideogram · Flux
Claude Code (local) 5 recorded answers
DALL-E · Midjourney · Flux · Ideogram · Adobe Firefly
Imagen · Flux · Midjourney · Adobe Firefly · Ideogram
Midjourney · Imagen · Flux · Ideogram · Adobe Firefly
Midjourney · Imagen · Adobe Firefly · Ideogram
Midjourney · Imagen · Adobe Firefly · Ideogram · Flux · Stable Diffusion
Codex (local) 5 recorded answers
Midjourney · Adobe Firefly · Ideogram
Midjourney · Adobe Firefly
Midjourney · Ideogram · Adobe Firefly
Midjourney · Adobe Firefly
Midjourney · Adobe Firefly · Ideogram
Gemini 5 recorded answers
Midjourney · Flux · NightCafe · Ideogram · Adobe Firefly
Midjourney · Flux · Ideogram · Adobe Firefly · Stable Diffusion
Midjourney · Ideogram · Recraft · Adobe Firefly · Flux · Stable Diffusion · Higgsfield
Midjourney · DALL-E · Imagen · Flux · NightCafe · Adobe Firefly
Midjourney · Flux · NightCafe · Adobe Firefly · Recraft · Ideogram
Perplexity 5 recorded answers
DALL-E · Midjourney · Ideogram · Adobe Firefly
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · DALL-E
Imagen · DALL-E · Midjourney · Adobe Firefly · Ideogram
Imagen · DALL-E · Midjourney · Adobe Firefly · Recraft
Imagen · Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · DALL-E

q02

Which AI makes the most realistic images? #

Named first most often: Flux (11 of 30 answers with these filters).

30 recorded attempts with these filters.

Read full answers to this question

ChatGPT 5 recorded answers
Imagen
DALL-E · Midjourney · Imagen
DALL-E · Imagen
DALL-E · Midjourney
DALL-E · Midjourney
Claude 5 recorded answers
Flux · Adobe Firefly · Midjourney
Flux · Midjourney
Imagen · Midjourney · Flux · Adobe Firefly
Flux · Midjourney · Ideogram
Flux · Midjourney · Ideogram
Claude Code (local) 5 recorded answers
Imagen · DALL-E · Flux · Krea · Freepik · getimg.ai · Midjourney · Seedream
Imagen · DALL-E · Flux · Krea · Freepik · Midjourney · Seedream
DALL-E · Imagen · Flux · Krea · Freepik · Leonardo AI · Seedream · Midjourney
Imagen · Flux · Krea · Freepik · DALL-E · Midjourney · Seedream
Imagen · DALL-E · Flux · Krea · Freepik · getimg.ai · Midjourney · Seedream
Codex (local) 5 recorded answers
No recognized brand was found
No recognized brand was found
Imagen · Midjourney
DALL-E · Midjourney · Flux
No recognized brand was found
Gemini 5 recorded answers
Flux · NightCafe · Midjourney · Imagen
Flux · NightCafe · Midjourney · Imagen · Leonardo AI
Flux · NightCafe · Freepik · Midjourney · Imagen · Stable Diffusion
Flux · Freepik · Midjourney · Imagen · Leonardo AI
Flux · Freepik · Midjourney · Imagen
Perplexity 5 recorded answers
Flux · Midjourney
Imagen · Flux · DALL-E · Midjourney
DALL-E · Imagen · Midjourney
Flux · Imagen · Midjourney
Imagen · Flux

q03

What is the best AI image generator for beginners? #

Named first most often: Canva (12 of 30 answers with these filters).

30 recorded attempts with these filters.

Read full answers to this question

ChatGPT 5 recorded answers
Canva
Canva
Canva
DALL-E · Canva
DALL-E · Canva
Claude 5 recorded answers
Imagen · Canva · Bing Image Creator · Adobe Firefly · Midjourney
Imagen · Bing Image Creator · Canva · Adobe Firefly · Leonardo AI · Midjourney
Imagen · Canva · Adobe Firefly · Midjourney
Imagen · Canva · Adobe Firefly · Midjourney
Imagen · Canva · Adobe Firefly · Midjourney
Claude Code (local) 5 recorded answers
Imagen · Canva · Adobe Firefly · Bing Image Creator · Midjourney
Imagen · Canva · Adobe Firefly · Midjourney
Imagen · Bing Image Creator · Canva · Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · Ideogram
Imagen · Bing Image Creator · Canva · Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · Ideogram
Imagen · Canva · Adobe Firefly · Midjourney
Codex (local) 5 recorded answers
Canva
Midjourney
Canva
Canva
Canva · Adobe Firefly
Gemini 5 recorded answers
DALL-E · Adobe Firefly · Canva · Ideogram
Imagen · Adobe Firefly · Canva · Ideogram
Adobe Firefly · Canva
Adobe Firefly · Canva
Bing Image Creator · Adobe Firefly · Canva · Midjourney
Perplexity 5 recorded answers
Canva · DALL-E · Adobe Firefly
Canva · Adobe Firefly
Canva · Adobe Firefly
Canva · Adobe Firefly
Canva

q04

Which AI image tool is best for commercial use? #

Named first most often: Adobe Firefly (30 of 30 answers with these filters).

30 recorded attempts with these filters.

Read full answers to this question

ChatGPT 5 recorded answers
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · DALL-E
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney
Claude 5 recorded answers
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · Ideogram · Flux
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · Ideogram · Leonardo AI
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · Ideogram · Flux
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · Ideogram · Flux · Stable Diffusion
Claude Code (local) 5 recorded answers
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · Flux
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · Ideogram · Stable Diffusion · Flux
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · Ideogram · Stable Diffusion · Flux
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · Imagen · Stable Diffusion
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · Imagen · Ideogram · Stable Diffusion · Flux
Codex (local) 5 recorded answers
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney
Adobe Firefly · DALL-E · Midjourney
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney
Gemini 5 recorded answers
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · Ideogram · Flux · Leonardo AI
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · Flux · Freepik · NightCafe · Canva · Leonardo AI
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · Ideogram · Flux · Stable Diffusion
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · Ideogram · Flux
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · Canva
Perplexity 5 recorded answers
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney

q05

What is the best free AI image generator? #

Named first most often: Imagen (16 of 30 answers with these filters).

30 recorded attempts with these filters.

Read full answers to this question

ChatGPT 5 recorded answers
Imagen · Bing Image Creator
Bing Image Creator · Imagen
Leonardo AI · Ideogram
Imagen · Bing Image Creator · Ideogram
Imagen · Ideogram · Bing Image Creator
Claude 5 recorded answers
Imagen · Bing Image Creator · Ideogram · Adobe Firefly · Canva · Leonardo AI · Stable Diffusion · Flux
Imagen · Bing Image Creator · Ideogram · Leonardo AI · Adobe Firefly
Imagen · Bing Image Creator · Ideogram · Adobe Firefly · Leonardo AI · Krea · Canva · Stable Diffusion · Flux
Imagen · Bing Image Creator · Ideogram · Adobe Firefly · Leonardo AI · Canva
Imagen · Bing Image Creator · Adobe Firefly · Ideogram · Krea · Midjourney · Recraft
Claude Code (local) 5 recorded answers
Bing Image Creator · Imagen · Ideogram · Leonardo AI · Stable Diffusion · Flux
Imagen · Bing Image Creator · Stable Diffusion · Flux · Ideogram · Leonardo AI · Adobe Firefly
Bing Image Creator · Imagen · Ideogram · Stable Diffusion · Flux · Leonardo AI · Adobe Firefly
Imagen · Bing Image Creator · Ideogram · Leonardo AI · Adobe Firefly · Stable Diffusion · Flux
Imagen · Bing Image Creator · Ideogram · Leonardo AI · Adobe Firefly · Stable Diffusion · Flux
Codex (local) 5 recorded answers
Bing Image Creator · Adobe Firefly
Bing Image Creator · Ideogram
Bing Image Creator · Ideogram
Bing Image Creator · Adobe Firefly
Bing Image Creator · Ideogram · Adobe Firefly
Gemini 5 recorded answers
Bing Image Creator · Ideogram · Leonardo AI · Imagen · Adobe Firefly · Krea · Flux
Bing Image Creator · Ideogram · Leonardo AI · Adobe Firefly
Bing Image Creator · Ideogram · Leonardo AI · Flux
Ideogram · Leonardo AI · Bing Image Creator · Adobe Firefly
Bing Image Creator · Ideogram · Leonardo AI · Krea · Imagen
Perplexity 5 recorded answers
Imagen · Canva · Leonardo AI · Ideogram
Imagen · Ideogram
Imagen · Ideogram · Bing Image Creator
Imagen · Bing Image Creator
Imagen · Bing Image Creator · Ideogram

q06

Which AI is best at generating text inside images? #

Named first most often: Ideogram (20 of 30 answers with these filters).

30 recorded attempts with these filters.

Read full answers to this question

ChatGPT 5 recorded answers
DALL-E · Ideogram
DALL-E · Ideogram · Imagen
DALL-E · Ideogram
DALL-E · Ideogram
DALL-E · Ideogram
Claude 5 recorded answers
Ideogram · Imagen
Ideogram · DALL-E · Imagen
Ideogram · Flux · Qwen-Image
Imagen · Ideogram
Ideogram · DALL-E · Imagen
Claude Code (local) 5 recorded answers
Ideogram · Midjourney · Flux · Adobe Firefly
DALL-E · Ideogram · Midjourney · Flux
DALL-E · Ideogram · Canva
Ideogram · DALL-E · Midjourney · Flux · Canva
Ideogram · Midjourney · Flux
Codex (local) 5 recorded answers
Ideogram · Canva
Ideogram · Canva
Ideogram · Canva
Ideogram · Canva
Ideogram
Gemini 5 recorded answers
Ideogram · Flux · Freepik · Recraft · DALL-E · Canva
Ideogram · Flux · NightCafe · Recraft
Ideogram · Flux · Canva
Ideogram · Recraft · Flux · DALL-E
Ideogram · Flux · Midjourney · DALL-E
Perplexity 5 recorded answers
Ideogram · Imagen
Ideogram · DALL-E · Imagen · Canva
Ideogram · DALL-E · Imagen
DALL-E · Ideogram
DALL-E · Ideogram

q07

What AI image generator do professional designers use? #

Named first most often: Adobe Firefly (20 of 30 answers with these filters).

30 recorded attempts with these filters.

Read full answers to this question

ChatGPT 5 recorded answers
Midjourney · Adobe Firefly · Recraft · Ideogram
Midjourney · Adobe Firefly · DALL-E
Midjourney · Adobe Firefly
Midjourney · Adobe Firefly · DALL-E
Midjourney · Adobe Firefly · DALL-E
Claude 5 recorded answers
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · Ideogram · Flux · Stable Diffusion · Canva
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · Imagen · Ideogram · Recraft · Flux · Stable Diffusion · Canva
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · Ideogram · Recraft · Stable Diffusion · Flux
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · Ideogram · Stable Diffusion · Flux · Canva
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · DALL-E · Imagen · Ideogram · Recraft · Krea · Flux · Stable Diffusion
Claude Code (local) 5 recorded answers
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · Ideogram · Recraft · Flux · Krea · Freepik
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · Ideogram · Recraft · Flux · Stable Diffusion
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · Ideogram · Stable Diffusion · Flux · Krea · Freepik
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · Imagen · Ideogram · Stable Diffusion · Flux · Canva · Krea
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · Stable Diffusion · Flux · Ideogram · Krea · Leonardo AI
Codex (local) 5 recorded answers
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · DALL-E
Midjourney · Adobe Firefly · DALL-E · Ideogram
Midjourney · Adobe Firefly · DALL-E
Midjourney · Adobe Firefly · DALL-E
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · DALL-E
Gemini 5 recorded answers
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · Recraft · Ideogram · Stable Diffusion · Flux
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · Recraft · Flux · Ideogram · Stable Diffusion
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · Recraft · Flux · Stable Diffusion · Ideogram · DALL-E
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · Recraft · Ideogram · Flux · Stable Diffusion
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · Recraft · Flux · Stable Diffusion · Ideogram
Perplexity 5 recorded answers
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · Ideogram · Recraft
Midjourney · Adobe Firefly
Midjourney · Adobe Firefly · Ideogram
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · Ideogram

q08

Which AI image generator gives the best value for money? #

Named first most often: Imagen (10 of 30 answers with these filters).

30 recorded attempts with these filters.

Read full answers to this question

ChatGPT 5 recorded answers
Leonardo AI · Midjourney
Adobe Firefly
Leonardo AI · Midjourney
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney
Adobe Firefly · Leonardo AI
Claude 5 recorded answers
Imagen · Midjourney · Ideogram · Bing Image Creator · Adobe Firefly · Stable Diffusion · Flux
Imagen · Midjourney · Leonardo AI · Ideogram · Adobe Firefly · Stable Diffusion · Flux
Imagen · Midjourney · Ideogram · Leonardo AI · Adobe Firefly · Stable Diffusion · Flux
Midjourney · Adobe Firefly · Stable Diffusion · Flux · Ideogram
Imagen · Bing Image Creator · Midjourney · Ideogram · Leonardo AI · Stable Diffusion · Flux
Claude Code (local) 5 recorded answers
Imagen · Midjourney · Bing Image Creator · Leonardo AI · Ideogram · Stable Diffusion · Flux
Imagen · Bing Image Creator · Ideogram · Leonardo AI · Midjourney · Stable Diffusion · Flux
Midjourney · Leonardo AI · Flux · Stable Diffusion
Midjourney · Imagen · Bing Image Creator · Ideogram · Adobe Firefly · Stable Diffusion · Flux
Imagen · Leonardo AI · Midjourney · Ideogram · Stable Diffusion · Flux
Codex (local) 5 recorded answers
Ideogram · Midjourney
Ideogram · Midjourney
Ideogram · Midjourney
Ideogram · Midjourney
Ideogram · Midjourney
Gemini 5 recorded answers
Leonardo AI · Bing Image Creator · Midjourney · Ideogram · Flux · Stable Diffusion
Midjourney · Bing Image Creator · Leonardo AI · Ideogram · Flux
Leonardo AI · Midjourney · Bing Image Creator
Flux · Stable Diffusion · Imagen · Leonardo AI · Midjourney · Ideogram
Flux · Stable Diffusion · Midjourney · Leonardo AI
Perplexity 5 recorded answers
Imagen · Adobe Firefly · Midjourney
Imagen · Midjourney
Leonardo AI · Midjourney
Midjourney
Imagen · Midjourney

q09

What is the best AI for generating logos? #

Named first most often: Recraft (14 of 30 answers with these filters).

30 recorded attempts with these filters.

Read full answers to this question

ChatGPT 5 recorded answers
No recognized brand was found
Canva · Recraft
Canva · Recraft
Recraft · Canva
Recraft · Canva
Claude 5 recorded answers
Recraft · Ideogram · Canva
Recraft · Ideogram · Canva
Recraft · Ideogram · Adobe Firefly · Canva
Canva · Ideogram · Midjourney · Recraft
Recraft · Ideogram · Canva
Claude Code (local) 5 recorded answers
Recraft · Ideogram · Midjourney · Canva
Ideogram · Recraft · Midjourney · Adobe Firefly · Canva
Ideogram · Recraft · Midjourney
Ideogram · Recraft · Midjourney · Canva · Adobe Firefly
Recraft · Ideogram · Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · Canva
Codex (local) 5 recorded answers
Ideogram
Recraft · Ideogram
Recraft
Recraft · Ideogram
Recraft · Ideogram
Gemini 5 recorded answers
Adobe Firefly · Recraft · Ideogram · Canva · Midjourney
Canva · Ideogram
Recraft · Ideogram · Canva
Canva · Recraft · Ideogram · Midjourney
Recraft · Ideogram · Midjourney · Canva
Perplexity 5 recorded answers
Canva
Canva · Recraft
Canva · Recraft
Canva
Canva · Recraft

q10

Which AI image generator has the best style control? #

Named first most often: Midjourney (23 of 30 answers with these filters).

30 recorded attempts with these filters.

Read full answers to this question

ChatGPT 5 recorded answers
Midjourney · Adobe Firefly
Midjourney · Adobe Firefly · Ideogram
Midjourney · Adobe Firefly
Midjourney
Midjourney
Claude 5 recorded answers
Midjourney · Stable Diffusion · Flux · Leonardo AI · getimg.ai · Ideogram
Midjourney · Stable Diffusion · Flux · Recraft · Leonardo AI · Ideogram
Midjourney · Stable Diffusion · Flux · Leonardo AI · Ideogram
Midjourney · Stable Diffusion · Flux · Leonardo AI · Ideogram
Midjourney · Stable Diffusion · Flux · Ideogram · Adobe Firefly
Claude Code (local) 5 recorded answers
Midjourney · Stable Diffusion · Flux · Krea · Adobe Firefly · Leonardo AI
Midjourney · Stable Diffusion · Flux · Krea · Adobe Firefly · Leonardo AI · Ideogram
Midjourney · Stable Diffusion · Flux · Adobe Firefly · Leonardo AI · Imagen
Midjourney · Stable Diffusion · Flux · Leonardo AI · Adobe Firefly · Ideogram · Imagen
Midjourney · Stable Diffusion · Flux · Adobe Firefly · Leonardo AI · Recraft · Imagen
Codex (local) 5 recorded answers
Midjourney · Adobe Firefly
Midjourney · Adobe Firefly
Midjourney · Adobe Firefly
Midjourney · Recraft · Adobe Firefly
Midjourney · Adobe Firefly
Gemini 5 recorded answers
Flux · Stable Diffusion · Midjourney · Leonardo AI · Recraft · Adobe Firefly
Stable Diffusion · Flux · Leonardo AI · Midjourney · Recraft
Stable Diffusion · Flux · Midjourney · Recraft · Adobe Firefly · Leonardo AI
Recraft · Midjourney · Adobe Firefly · Stable Diffusion · Flux
Stable Diffusion · Flux · Recraft · Leonardo AI · Midjourney
Perplexity 5 recorded answers
Midjourney · Adobe Firefly
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney
Midjourney · Adobe Firefly
Adobe Firefly
Midjourney · Adobe Firefly

q11

What is the best AI image generator for marketing images? #

Named first most often: Adobe Firefly (18 of 30 answers with these filters).

30 recorded attempts with these filters.

Read full answers to this question

ChatGPT 5 recorded answers
Adobe Firefly · DALL-E · Ideogram · Canva
Adobe Firefly · Canva
Adobe Firefly · Canva
Adobe Firefly · Canva · DALL-E
Adobe Firefly · Canva · DALL-E
Claude 5 recorded answers
Adobe Firefly · Canva · Ideogram · Recraft · Midjourney · Imagen
DALL-E · Imagen · Midjourney · Canva · Adobe Firefly · Ideogram · Recraft
Midjourney · Adobe Firefly · Canva · Ideogram · Imagen · Recraft
Imagen · Midjourney · Adobe Firefly · Ideogram · Recraft · Canva
Imagen · Midjourney · Ideogram · Adobe Firefly · Canva · Recraft
Claude Code (local) 5 recorded answers
Midjourney · Adobe Firefly · Ideogram · Canva · Imagen · Flux
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · Ideogram · Canva · Flux · Freepik · Krea · Leonardo AI
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · Ideogram · Canva · Leonardo AI · getimg.ai
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · Canva
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · Canva · Ideogram
Codex (local) 5 recorded answers
Adobe Firefly · DALL-E · Midjourney
Adobe Firefly · DALL-E · Canva · Midjourney
Adobe Firefly · DALL-E · Canva
DALL-E · Canva · Adobe Firefly
DALL-E · Adobe Firefly · Canva
Gemini 5 recorded answers
Midjourney · Ideogram · Adobe Firefly · Canva
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · Ideogram · Canva
Midjourney · Adobe Firefly · Ideogram · Canva · Recraft · getimg.ai
Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · Ideogram · Canva
Adobe Firefly · Ideogram · Midjourney · Canva · Recraft
Perplexity 5 recorded answers
Canva · Adobe Firefly
Adobe Firefly · Canva
Canva · Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · Ideogram
Adobe Firefly · Canva · Midjourney · Ideogram
Canva · Adobe Firefly

q12

Which AI image tool is best for editing existing photos? #

Named first most often: Imagen (13 of 30 answers with these filters).

30 recorded attempts with these filters.

Hide full answer text

ChatGPT 5 recorded answers
DALL-E
Read answer 1 · 18:38 UTC

**Adobe Photoshop is my pick for editing existing photos** if you want the most control. It combines AI tools for removing objects, filling or expanding a scene, and retouching with conventional editing tools for fine adjustments. ([helpx.adobe.com](https://helpx.adobe.com/photoshop/desktop/generative-ai/use-ai-assisted-mode.html?utm_source=openai)) If you want something simpler, **ChatGPT Images** lets you upload a photo and describe the change, or select the area to edit. For quick fixes to phone photos—like erasing a distraction—**Google Photos** is the easier choice. ([help.openai.com](https://help.openai.com/en/articles/11084440-images-in-chatgpt?utm_source=openai)) So: **Photoshop for serious editing; ChatGPT for prompt-based changes; Google Photos for quick touch-ups.**

Sources were recorded as citations in the answer.

Imagen
Read answer 2 · 18:38 UTC

**Adobe Photoshop is my pick for editing existing photos.** Its Generative Fill and Remove tools let you change specific parts of a photo, while its traditional editing tools give you precise control when the AI result needs a touch-up. ([helpx.adobe.com](https://helpx.adobe.com/photoshop/desktop/create-open-import-images/create-images/edit-images-with-generative-fill.html?utm_source=openai)) If you’d rather **upload a photo and describe the change in plain English**, try **Google Gemini** first. For quick edits to photos you’re putting into a design, **Canva Magic Edit** is another simple option. ([blog.google](https://blog.google/products-and-platforms/products/gemini/image-editing/?utm_source=openai)) **Bottom line:** Photoshop for the best all-around editing workflow; Gemini for the easiest starting point.

Sources were recorded as citations in the answer.

DALL-E
Read answer 3 · 18:38 UTC

**Adobe Photoshop is my pick for editing existing photos.** Its Generative Fill lets you select a specific area to remove or replace something while keeping the rest of the photo under your control. It’s the best fit if you want careful, repeatable edits, though it requires a subscription and has a learning curve. ([helpx.adobe.com](https://helpx.adobe.com/photoshop/desktop/make-selections/refine-modify-selections/use-selections-for-generative-editing.html?utm_source=openai)) If you want something simpler: - **Google Photos** for quick phone edits, such as removing distractions or improving a snapshot. ([google.com](https://www.google.com/intl/en/photos/editing/?utm_source=openai)) - **ChatGPT Images** if you’d rather upload a photo and describe the change in plain English. It’s easy to use, but edits can extend beyond the area you select. ([help.openai.com](https://help.openai.com/en/articles/11084440-images-in-chatgpt?utm_source=openai)) - **Adobe Lightroom** if you mainly want to improve your photographs—exposure, noise, blur and cleanup—rather than replace parts of a scene. ([helpx.adobe.com](https://helpx.adobe.com/lightroom/mobile/manage-ai-edits/update-ai-edits.html?utm_source=openai)) **Bottom line:** choose **Photoshop** for the most control; try **Google Photos** first for casual edits.

Sources were recorded as citations in the answer.

DALL-E
Read answer 4 · 18:38 UTC

**Adobe Photoshop is my pick for editing existing photos.** Its Generative Fill lets you select just the area you want to change—remove a person, replace an object, or extend the frame—while keeping the rest of the photo editable. That control is the main reason I’d choose it over a prompt-only image tool. ([helpx.adobe.com](https://helpx.adobe.com/photoshop/desktop/create-open-import-images/create-images/edit-images-with-generative-fill.html?utm_source=openai)) If you want something easier, **ChatGPT Images** lets you upload a photo and describe the change in plain English. For quick phone-photo touch-ups, **Google Photos** is simpler still. ([help.openai.com](https://help.openai.com/en/articles/11084440-images-in-chatgpt?utm_source=openai)) **Bottom line:** Photoshop for precise edits; ChatGPT Images for quick, conversational ones.

Sources were recorded as citations in the answer.

DALL-E
Read answer 5 · 18:38 UTC

**Adobe Photoshop is my pick for editing existing photos.** It gives you AI tools to remove distractions, add or replace parts of a scene, and expand a photo, while still offering precise manual controls when an AI edit needs cleanup. ([helpx.adobe.com](https://helpx.adobe.com/photoshop/desktop/generative-ai/use-ai-assisted-mode.html?utm_source=openai)) If you want something simpler, choose based on the job: - **Google Photos** for quick everyday fixes, such as removing an object, unblurring a shot, or adjusting lighting. ([google.com](https://www.google.com/photos/editing/?utm_source=openai)) - **ChatGPT Images** for conversational edits: upload a photo, describe what you want changed, and optionally select the area to edit. It’s convenient for creative changes, though selections may affect more than the area you marked. ([help.openai.com](https://help.openai.com/en/articles/11084440-images-in-chatgpt?utm_source=openai)) **Bottom line:** Photoshop for the most control; Google Photos for quick touch-ups; ChatGPT for “make this look like…” edits.

Sources were recorded as citations in the answer.

Claude 5 recorded answers
Imagen · Flux
Read answer 1 · 18:28 UTC

For most people, I'd go with **Google's Nano Banana**, which is the image model built into the Gemini app. For professional work, use **Adobe Photoshop**. **Best overall: Google Gemini (Nano Banana 2 or Nano Banana Pro)** - In recent tests it comes out on top for editing real photos. You describe the change in plain language, and it keeps faces and the rest of the scene looking the same. - Fstoppers tested adding products into existing photos. Nano Banana Pro beat ChatGPT, with more natural shadows and reflections. - Nano Banana 2 is free to use at standard resolutions, so it's good value for everyday edits. **Best for professional control: Adobe Photoshop (Generative Fill and the Remove tool)** - You get masks, layers, edits you can undo later, and batch processing across a whole folder of images. Chat-based tools can't do these things. - Photoshop now lets you choose Google's Nano Banana models inside Generative Fill, so you can get similar AI quality with Photoshop's precision tools. **Good alternative: ChatGPT (OpenAI's image model)** - It's handy if you already pay for ChatGPT, and the final images look polished. In side-by-side tests, though, it's usually a bit less precise than Nano Banana at keeping the original photo intact. **For developers or bulk edits: FLUX Kontext / FLUX.2 from Black Forest Labs** - It's cheap per image through an API and good at making a series of edits while keeping the subject consistent. **My pick:** - Quick fixes, removing objects, swapping backgrounds, or restyling: **Gemini**, which is free to start. - Client or print work where every pixel matters: **Photoshop**. - Mostly simple cleanup on your phone: the free built-in tools are fine, like **Google Photos Magic Editor** or **Samsung Galaxy AI**.

Sources were recorded as search results.

Imagen · Flux
Read answer 2 · 18:28 UTC

There isn't one clear winner. The best tool depends on what kind of edit you're making: **For most people: Google Gemini (Nano Banana) or ChatGPT (GPT Image)** - **Gemini / Nano Banana Pro** is the easiest choice for edits you describe in plain words. One reviewer called it "easily the most powerful image editing (aka inpainting) app I've seen to date." TechRadar notes you can even tell the model to pretend the lighting setup was entirely different from the start. It's also cheap and fast. One comparison says it generates images in under 1.5 seconds at the lowest price per image. - **ChatGPT / GPT Image 2** is better when you want everything else in the photo left alone. In one test, GPT Image 2.5 Flare and FLUX.3 Image changed only what was asked , while Nano Banana 2 and FLUX.2 Pro produced the boldest rain and lettering but rebuilt part of the room to do it. Another review ranks GPT Image 2 as the best AI image editor on blind-preference leaderboards. **Keeping a person's face consistent: FLUX Kontext (Black Forest Labs)** One guide recommends "Flux Kontext for identity, Nano Banana for everything else" . It says Flux Kontext preserves subject identity through full background swaps. **Precise, professional retouching: Adobe Photoshop** Typing instructions into a chatbot has limits. With Nano Banana Pro, certain "retouch this exact region" tasks don't work reliably , and it sometimes recreates the whole image instead of editing one section . Photoshop's Generative Fill lets you select the exact area to change and keeps you in full manual control. **Specific fixes:** Luminar Neo is best for quick AI editing for casual content creators , and Topaz Photo AI is best for fixing blurry or low-light photos. **My pick:** Start with Gemini (Nano Banana) for quick, casual edits. Use ChatGPT when the rest of the photo has to stay exactly as it is, and Photoshop for client or print work.

Sources were recorded as search results.

Imagen · Canva
Read answer 3 · 18:28 UTC

The best choice depends on the kind of editing you're doing, but in early 2026 most people should start with one of these two: **Best for most people: Google Gemini (Nano Banana Pro)** - You upload a photo and type what you want, like "remove the people in the background," "make it sunset," or "change the jacket to red." - It's good at keeping faces and other details the same across several rounds of edits, which is where many AI editors struggle. - You can use it for free in the Gemini app. A paid plan raises the limits and adds higher-resolution output. **Best for precise or professional work: Adobe Photoshop (Generative Fill, powered by Firefly)** - You select the exact area to change, so the rest of the photo stays untouched. It also gives the highest-resolution generative edits. - It includes layers, masking and retouching tools that chat-based tools don't have. - Adobe trains Firefly on licensed content, so it's the safer pick if you'll use the images commercially. - It's a paid subscription. Firefly alone starts at about $5/month for a small number of credits. **Other good options:** - **ChatGPT (OpenAI's image model):** Works much like Gemini, with conversational edits. It's strong for creative changes but tends to alter details you didn't ask it to touch. - **Canva:** The easiest choice for quick social posts, such as background removal, magic erase and templates. - **Adobe Lightroom or Luminar Neo:** Better if you want to improve real photos (lighting, sky replacement, noise reduction, removing distractions) rather than reimagine them. - **YouCam Perfect or Picsart (mobile):** Good for selfies, portrait touch-ups and quick edits on your phone. **My recommendation:** Try Gemini's Nano Banana first, since it's free and handles most edits well. If you need pixel-level control, print-quality resolution or images that are safe for commercial use, go with Photoshop.

Sources were recorded as search results.

Flux · Canva
Read answer 4 · 18:28 UTC

For most people, I'd pick **Google's Gemini "Nano Banana"** for quick edits you describe in plain English, and **Adobe Photoshop** if you need precise, professional control. Which one is best depends on how you work: **Best for quick edits from a text prompt: Google Gemini (Nano Banana / Nano Banana Pro)** - You upload a photo and type what you want, like "remove the fence and add clouds." It does that kind of change well in one step, without you having to select anything by hand. - It's good at keeping people and the rest of the scene looking the same. - It's free to try in the Gemini app. **ChatGPT's image editing** works the same way and is a close alternative. **Best for precise, professional work: Adobe Photoshop (Generative Fill)** - You choose exactly which part of the photo to change, and edits go on separate layers, so you can undo or adjust them later. - It can apply the same edit to a whole folder of photos automatically. The chat-style tools can't do that. - Photoshop now lets you run Google's Nano Banana and FLUX models inside Generative Fill, so you get the newer models plus Adobe's selection tools. - It costs from about $19.99/month, and generative edits use up credits. **Other options:** - **Luminar Neo:** Good for improving photos, like sky replacement, portrait retouching and relighting. You can buy it once for about $129 instead of paying monthly. Several review sites rate it highly. - **Canva, Picsart or Pixlr:** Cheap, easy options for social media posts and simple fixes like removing objects or backgrounds. - **Topaz Photo AI:** Best for sharpening, removing grain and enlarging old or blurry photos. **In short:** Try Gemini first since it's free. If you edit photos seriously or a lot, Photoshop is the stronger tool. If you'd rather not pay a subscription, Luminar Neo is the best one-time purchase.

Sources were recorded as search results.

Imagen · Flux · Canva
Read answer 5 · 18:28 UTC

For most people, the best pick right now is **Google Gemini's Nano Banana Pro**. For professional or high-resolution work, use **Adobe Photoshop**. **Best overall: Google Gemini (Nano Banana Pro / Nano Banana 2)** - You describe the change in plain language, like "remove the person on the left" or "make it sunset," and it does it. You usually don't have to select the area first, the way you do in Photoshop. - It's especially good at keeping faces and people looking the same across edits, which is where many other tools fall short. - You can use it free in the Gemini app with usage limits. Google AI Pro raises the limits. **Best for professionals: Adobe Photoshop (Generative Fill)** - It gives you full control with layers, edits that don't overwrite the original, and full-resolution output. It can also apply the same edit to a whole folder of images automatically. - Generative Fill now lets you pick other companies' models, including Google's Nano Banana and Black Forest Labs' FLUX, alongside Adobe's own Firefly. So you get top-tier AI without leaving Photoshop. - Adobe trains Firefly on licensed images, which matters if you're using the results commercially. - Downsides: it costs about $23 a month and is hard to learn. **Also worth trying:** - **ChatGPT (OpenAI's GPT Image models):** It ranks at or near the top of blind-preference leaderboards and is the best at handling text in images, like signs and labels. - **FLUX Kontext:** Good for retouching portraits and product photos, because it keeps natural skin and surface texture so the result still looks like a real photo. - **Canva:** Easiest if you're making quick social media graphics from templates. **Quick guide:** - For casual edits on your phone or computer, start with Gemini. It's free. - For serious retouching, print work, or client work, get Photoshop. - If your edits involve text, try ChatGPT. These tools are updated every few months, so rankings change quickly. The best test is to run the same photo through Gemini and ChatGPT, since both are free to try, and see which result you like better.

Sources were recorded as search results.

Claude Code (local) 5 recorded answers
Imagen
Read answer 1 · 18:38 UTC

There isn't one best tool. It depends on what kind of editing you're doing. **Best overall for most people: Adobe Photoshop (Generative Fill / Firefly)** - Very good at removing objects, extending backgrounds and replacing parts of an image while keeping the rest untouched. - Has precise selection tools and layers, and edits are non-destructive. - Adobe trains its models on licensed content, which matters if you use the images commercially. - Downside: it's a subscription (about $10–23/month for the Photography or Photoshop plans). **Best for editing by describing changes: Google Gemini (Nano Banana image model) or ChatGPT (GPT image model)** - You upload a photo and describe the change, like "make it sunset" or "put him in a suit." - Both are good at keeping faces and details consistent across several rounds of edits. Gemini currently has a slight edge on preserving how people look. - Free tiers are available, with paid plans around $20/month. - Downside: you get less pixel-level control than in Photoshop. **Best free or cheap options** - **Google Photos Magic Editor** or **Samsung Galaxy AI**: fine for quick phone fixes like removing objects or moving subjects. - **Canva Magic Edit**: easy, and good if you're already making designs in Canva. - **Photoroom** or **Picsart**: good for product photos and background removal. **Best for retouching and enhancement** - **Lightroom** (AI masking, Denoise, removing distractions) for photographers. - **Topaz Photo AI** for upscaling, sharpening and noise reduction. It's a one-time purchase. **My recommendation:** - For serious or commercial work, use Photoshop. - For fast, impressive edits from plain-language prompts, try Gemini or ChatGPT first since they're free to start. - For everyday phone photos, the editor built into your phone is probably enough. These tools update every few months, so check recent comparisons before you pay for a subscription.

How sources were used was not recorded.

    Imagen · Canva
    Read answer 2 · 18:38 UTC

    It depends on the kind of editing you're doing, but these are the strongest options: **Best overall for photo editing: Adobe Photoshop (Generative Fill / Firefly)** - You can select part of a photo and add, remove or replace things using a text prompt, with full manual control on top. - The edits blend well with the original lighting and perspective, and it keeps your original image's resolution. - It costs about $20–23/month, and it's the best pick if you want professional-quality results. **Best for editing by just describing changes: Google Gemini (the "Nano Banana" image model) or ChatGPT image editing** - You upload a photo and type something like "remove the people in the background" or "make it sunset." No editing skills needed. - Gemini is especially good at keeping faces and details consistent across edits. - Both are free to start, with paid tiers for more use. **Best free or casual option: Google Photos Magic Editor, or Samsung/Apple's built-in tools** - They're good for quick object removal, relighting and reframing on your phone. **Best budget alternative to Photoshop: Canva Magic Studio or Pixlr** - They're easy to use and handle background removal, object erase and generative edits well enough for social media. **Specialized tools:** - **Topaz Photo AI**: upscaling, sharpening and noise reduction - **Lightroom (AI Denoise, Generative Remove)**: photographers editing in batches - **Remove.bg / Clipdrop**: fast background or object removal **My pick:** For serious editing, get Photoshop. For quick edits by just describing what you want, try Gemini first. These tools update often, so it's worth checking recent reviews before you pay for a subscription.

    How sources were used was not recorded.

      Imagen · Canva · Flux · Stable Diffusion
      Read answer 3 · 18:38 UTC

      The best choice depends on the kind of editing you want to do: **Best overall for photo editing: Adobe Photoshop (Generative Fill / Firefly)** - You can select part of a photo and add, remove or replace things with a text prompt. It works on layers, so the rest of the image stays untouched. - It also has strong traditional editing tools for finishing the job. - Adobe's commercial-use terms are among the clearest available. - Downside: it needs a subscription, and Photoshop takes some time to learn. **Best for quick edits using plain language: Google Gemini (the "Nano Banana" image models) or ChatGPT image editing** - You upload a photo and type something like "remove the people in the background" or "make it sunset." Both are very good at keeping faces and details consistent. - Gemini is especially strong at keeping a person looking like themselves across several edits. - Downside: you get less precise control, and the output resolution can be limited. **Best free or casual option on a phone: Google Photos Magic Editor, or Samsung/Apple's built-in tools** - These handle removing objects, moving subjects and changing the sky without any extra app. **Best for specific tasks:** - **Retouching and portraits:** Lightroom, which has AI masking and Generative Remove - **Upscaling and restoring old photos:** Topaz Photo AI - **Removing backgrounds:** Canva or remove.bg - **Maximum control for free, if you're technical:** Flux Kontext or Stable Diffusion, either through ComfyUI or through Krita's AI plugin **My recommendation:** For occasional edits, start with Gemini or ChatGPT because they're fast and need no skill. For serious or professional work, Photoshop with Generative Fill is still the most dependable. These tools change quickly, so it's worth checking current pricing and features before you subscribe.

      How sources were used was not recorded.

        Imagen
        Read answer 4 · 18:38 UTC

        It depends on how you edit, but here are the best picks: **Best overall: Adobe Photoshop (Generative Fill / Firefly)** - Precise control: you select an area and tell it what to add, remove, or replace, and it works alongside layers, masks, and normal editing tools. - Best if you want professional results and don't mind paying for a subscription (the Photography plan is the cheapest way in). **Best for editing by describing changes: Google Gemini (the "Nano Banana" image model) or ChatGPT (OpenAI's image generation)** - You upload a photo and type something like "remove the people in the background" or "make it sunset." - Gemini is especially good at keeping faces and details consistent from one edit to the next. - Easy to use and cheap or free to start, but you get less fine control than in Photoshop. **Best for quick fixes on your phone:** - **Google Photos (Magic Editor / Magic Eraser)** or **Samsung Galaxy AI** for removing objects and moving subjects around. - **Apple Photos (Clean Up)** on newer iPhones and Macs. - All free if your device supports them. **Other good options:** - **Adobe Lightroom**: AI masking and Generative Remove, great for photographers editing lots of shots. - **Canva Magic Edit**: simple and good for social media content. - **Luminar Neo**: one-time purchase, good AI sky replacement and portrait tools. **Quick recommendation:** - Serious or professional work: **Photoshop**. - Casual edits by typing what you want: **Gemini** or **ChatGPT**. - Quick cleanups on your phone: your phone's built-in photo app. These tools change quickly, so check current pricing and free tiers before you subscribe.

        How sources were used was not recorded.

          Imagen · Canva · Flux · Krea · Freepik · Stable Diffusion
          Read answer 5 · 18:39 UTC

          The right tool depends on what kind of editing you're doing: **Best overall for most people: Adobe Photoshop (Generative Fill / Firefly)** - Very good at removing objects, extending backgrounds and replacing parts of a photo while keeping the rest untouched. - Its masking and layers give you precise control, and the training data is licensed, so it's safer for commercial use. - Downside: you need a subscription (about $10–23/month). **Best for editing by just describing the change: Google Gemini (Nano Banana image models) or ChatGPT image editing** - You upload a photo and type what you want, like "change the jacket to red" or "make it sunset." No editing skills needed. - Gemini is especially good at keeping faces and details consistent across several edits. - Both have free tiers, with more use on paid plans. **Best for quick, cheap touch-ups:** - **Canva Magic Edit / Magic Eraser**: easy and good enough for social media. - **Google Photos Magic Editor** or **Samsung Galaxy AI**: free on supported phones and great for removing people or objects. - **Photoroom**: best for product photos and background removal. **Best for pros and power users:** - **Adobe Lightroom**: AI masking, denoise and batch retouching for photographers. - **Flux Kontext** (through Krea, Freepik and similar sites) or **Stable Diffusion with ComfyUI**: the most control and flexibility, but more of a learning curve. **My recommendation:** For precise, high-quality edits, use Photoshop. For fast, easy edits where you just describe what you want, start with Gemini's free tier. One caveat: these tools change quickly, so check recent reviews before you pay for a subscription.

          How sources were used was not recorded.

            Codex (local) 5 recorded answers
            Imagen · DALL-E
            Read answer 1 · 18:39 UTC

            **Adobe Photoshop is my best overall pick for editing existing photos**, especially when you want precise control over what changes. Its AI tools can add or remove objects and extend backgrounds, while its editing tools let you refine the result. The tradeoffs are cost and a learning curve. [Adobe’s features](https://helpx.adobe.com/photoshop/desktop/generative-ai/generative-ai-features-overview.html) For simpler needs: - **Google Gemini:** A good choice for uploading a photo and describing creative changes, such as a different outfit or background. [Gemini image editing](https://blog.google/products-and-platforms/products/gemini/updated-image-editing-model/) - **ChatGPT Images:** Convenient for conversational editing—upload a photo, describe the change, then refine it through follow-up requests. [Editing capabilities](https://help.openai.com/en/articles/11084440-images-in-chatgpt) - **Google Photos:** My pick for everyday phone-photo cleanup, with tools such as Magic Eraser and Photo Unblur. [Photo tools](https://www.google.com/intl/en/photos/editing/) For photos where faces, products, or fine details must stay accurate, I’d choose **Photoshop** and apply edits to selected areas.

            How sources were used was not recorded.

              No recognized brand was found
              Read answer 2 · 18:39 UTC

              **Adobe Photoshop is my pick for editing existing photos**, especially when you want precise control. Its Generative Fill lets you change selected areas, remove distractions, or add objects, with nondestructive editing so you can refine the result. The downside is the learning curve. [Photoshop editing features](https://helpx.adobe.com/photoshop/desktop/create-open-import-images/create-images/edit-images-with-generative-fill.html) **ChatGPT is an easier option for occasional edits:** upload a photo and describe what you want changed. It’s convenient for background swaps and creative transformations, though you should inspect details you wanted preserved. [ChatGPT image editing](https://help.openai.com/en/articles/11084440-chatgpt-image-library/) I’d choose **Photoshop for precision**, and **ChatGPT for convenience**.

              How sources were used was not recorded.

                DALL-E
                Read answer 3 · 18:39 UTC

                **Adobe Photoshop is my best overall pick for editing existing photos.** Its combination of precise selections, layers, and AI Generative Fill gives you control over exactly what changes—useful for removing objects, replacing backgrounds, or extending a photo. Edits can be made nondestructively so you can revise them later. [Photoshop features](https://helpx.adobe.com/photoshop/desktop/create-open-import-images/create-images/edit-images-with-generative-fill.html) **For easy, occasional edits, I’d choose ChatGPT Images.** Upload a photo and describe what you want changed. It’s a simpler starting point if you don’t want to learn a photo editor. [Image editing in ChatGPT](https://help.openai.com/en/articles/11084440-images-in-chatgpt) My recommendation: **Photoshop for precision; ChatGPT for convenience.**

                How sources were used was not recorded.

                  Canva
                  Read answer 4 · 18:39 UTC

                  **Adobe Photoshop is my best overall pick for editing existing photos.** Its Generative Fill lets you change selected areas non-destructively, and its conventional editing tools give you control over the final result. It’s especially useful when precision matters. [Adobe’s editing guide](https://helpx.adobe.com/photoshop/desktop/create-open-import-images/create-images/edit-images-with-generative-fill.html) For simpler needs: - **ChatGPT:** My pick for easy edits using plain-language instructions—upload a photo and describe the changes. [Image editing details](https://help.openai.com/en/articles/11084440-images-in-chatgpt) - **Canva:** A good choice for quick background changes, object removal, and photos destined for social posts or presentations. [Canva’s photo tools](https://www.canva.com/features/ai-photo-editing/) I’d choose **Photoshop for control** or **ChatGPT for convenience**.

                  How sources were used was not recorded.

                    No recognized brand was found
                    Read answer 5 · 18:39 UTC

                    **Adobe Photoshop is my best overall pick for editing existing photos**, especially when you want precise control over what changes. Its Generative Fill makes targeted, nondestructive edits, and its editing tools let you refine the result. [Photoshop editing features](https://helpx.adobe.com/photoshop/desktop/create-open-import-images/create-images/edit-images-with-generative-fill.html) **ChatGPT is my pick for easy, occasional edits.** Upload a photo and describe what you want—such as removing an object or changing the background—without learning a full photo editor. [ChatGPT image editing](https://help.openai.com/en/articles/11084440-images-in-chatgpt) For carefully finished photos, choose **Photoshop**. For quick “change this for me” requests, start with **ChatGPT**.

                    How sources were used was not recorded.

                      Gemini 5 recorded answers
                      Adobe Firefly · Canva
                      Read answer 1 · 18:38 UTC

                      The best AI image tool for editing existing photos depends on **what kind of edits you need to make**: ### 1. Best Overall & Most Powerful: **Adobe Photoshop (with Firefly AI)** * **Best for:** Seamless object removal, expanding image borders (Generative Expand), adding or replacing elements with text prompts, and precision editing. * **Why it stands out:** Photoshop’s AI (powered by Adobe Firefly) integrates directly into traditional editing layers. It matches lighting, shadows, and textures better than almost any other editor. * **Alternative (Web):** If you don’t want to pay for a Photoshop subscription, **Adobe Firefly’s web app** allows you to upload photos and use Generative Fill for free with monthly credits. ### 2. Best Easy-to-Use Web Tool: **Canva** * **Best for:** Fast edits, social media posts, and quick cleanups. * **Why it stands out:** Canva’s AI features (**Magic Edit**, **Magic Eraser**, and **Magic Expand**) let you select an object with a brush to change, remove, or replace it without needing professional photo editing skills. ### 3. Best for Photographers & Portrait Touch-Ups: **Luminar Neo** * **Best for:** Landscape adjustments, lighting fixes, sky replacement, and portrait retouching. * **Why it stands out:** Luminar Neo focuses on photo enhancement rather than creating fake elements from scratch. It excels at tasks like removing powerlines, smoothing skin, relighting dark foregrounds, and replacing boring skies naturally. ### 4. Best for Fixing Blurry or Low-Quality Photos: **Topaz Photo AI** * **Best for:** AI upscaling, noise reduction, sharpening blurry faces, and restoring old or low-resolution shots. * **Why it stands out:** If your main goal is fixing technical flaws (out-of-focus subjects, pixelation, or grainy low-light shots) rather than altering content, Topaz provides unmatched detail recovery. ### 5. Best for Product Photography & E-commerce: **Photoroom** * **Best for:** Removing backgrounds, adding studio-quality backdrops, and cleaning up item shots. * **Why it stands out:** Extremely fast mobile and web editor that automatically isolates products and lets you generate realistic AI studio backgrounds. --- ### **Quick Recommendation** * Choose **Adobe Photoshop / Firefly** if you want top-tier professional control and generative editing. * Choose **Canva** if you want quick, simple edits in a web browser. * Choose **Topaz Photo AI** if you are trying to make a low-quality photo sharp and clear.

                      How sources were used was not recorded.

                      Canva
                      Read answer 2 · 18:38 UTC

                      The "best" AI tool for editing existing photos depends on what kind of editing you're doing—whether you want precise professional control, fast social media edits, photo restoration, or object removal. Here are the top tools broken down by use case: ### 1. **Adobe Photoshop (with Firefly)** — *Best Overall for Professionals & Precise Edits* * **Why it’s the best:** Photoshop’s AI-powered **Generative Fill** and **Generative Expand** tools remain the gold standard. You can select any part of a photo using a brush and type a simple text prompt to add, remove, or replace elements seamlessly, matched to lighting and perspective. * **Best for:** Complex photo manipulation, removing unwanted background objects, expanding photo borders, and high-resolution work. ### 2. **Canva** — *Best for Beginners & Quick Social Media Edits* * **Why it’s the best:** Canva’s **Magic Studio** features (Magic Eraser, Magic Grab, and Magic Edit) make editing intuitive. "Magic Grab" lets you click on a person or object in a photo to separate it from the background instantly, resize it, or move it somewhere else. * **Best for:** Content creators, graphic design integration, and fast one-click adjustments. ### 3. **Topaz Photo AI** — *Best for Enhancing, Sharpening, & Restoring Quality* * **Why it’s the best:** Unlike generative prompt tools, Topaz focuses on fixing image technical flaws. Its AI automatically removes noise, sharpens soft/blurry focus, and upscales low-resolution photos without destroying natural details. * **Best for:** Restoring old photos, fixing out-of-focus shots, and upscaling images for print. ### 4. **Luminar Neo** — *Best Desktop App for Landscape & Portrait Photographers* * **Why it’s the best:** Luminar Neo uses AI to automate tedious photography edits like skin smoothing, relighting uneven scenes, sky replacement, and portrait retouching while preserving a natural look. * **Best for:** Enthusiast and professional photographers who want fast enhancements without prompt engineering. ### 5. **Photoroom** — *Best for Product Photography & E-Commerce* * **Why it’s the best:** Photoroom automatically isolates subjects from their backgrounds and generates studio-quality AI background environments around them. * **Best for:** Sellers listing items on eBay, Etsy, or Shopify, and quick phone-based product edits. ### 6. **Google Photos (built-in)** — *Best Free Everyday Mobile Tool* * **Why it’s the best:** Available right on your smartphone, Google Photos includes **Magic Eraser** (clears background clutter), **Photo Unblur** (fixes camera shake), and Gemini-powered image editing prompt controls for quick touch-ups on existing shots. --- ### Which should you pick? * **For complete control and seamless blending:** Go with **Adobe Photoshop**. * **For quick, easy, web-based edits:** Go with **Canva**. * **For fixing blurry or low-res images:** Go with **Topaz Photo AI**.

                      How sources were used was not recorded.

                      Canva
                      Read answer 3 · 18:38 UTC

                      The best AI tool for editing an existing photo depends on the type of edit you need. Here are the top recommendations categorized by specific editing tasks: ### 1. Best Overall & Precision Control: **Adobe Photoshop** (with Adobe Firefly) If you need seamless, professional-grade control over uploaded photos, Photoshop is the gold standard. * **Key Features:** **Generative Fill** (add, change, or replace objects using text prompts), **Generative Expand** (outpaint image borders smoothly), and the **Remove Tool** (instantly clean up unwanted objects or people without leaving visual artifacts). * **Best for:** Complex edits, seamless blending, object replacement, and commercial work. ### 2. Best for Quick, Easy Web & Social Edits: **Canva** Canva’s **Magic Studio** features make editing uploaded images intuitive for non-professionals. * **Key Features:** **Magic Eraser** (brush away distraction objects), **Magic Edit** (swap an item for something else via text prompt), and **Magic Grab** (separate the foreground subject from the background so you can move or resize it independently). * **Best for:** Casual users, content creators, and social media graphics. ### 3. Best for Enhancing Quality & Detail (Upscaling/Unblurring): **Topaz Photo AI** If your existing photo is low-resolution, blurry, or noisy, generative AI editors might alter facial features unnaturally. Topaz specializes in pure photo enhancement. * **Key Features:** Sharpening out-of-focus shots, removing high-ISO digital noise, and upscaling image resolution up to 600% without loss of sharpness. * **Best for:** Restoring old photos, fixing camera blur, and printing high-res images. ### 4. Best for Product & E-Commerce Photos: **Photoroom** Designed specifically for online sellers and marketers. * **Key Features:** Instant background removal, AI-generated realistic studio lighting/backgrounds for products, and batch editing. * **Best for:** E-commerce listings, eBay/Shopify sellers, and professional product shots. ### 5. Best Free Built-In Mobile Editor: **Google Photos** If you want fast fixes straight from your phone, Google Photos' built-in AI suite is tough to beat. * **Key Features:** **Magic Eraser** for removing background clutter, **Photo Unblur** for fixing motion blur, and conversational edits via Gemini. * **Best for:** Quick mobile touch-ups on everyday personal photos. --- ### **Quick Recommendation:** * Go with **Canva** or **Google Photos** for quick, simple object removal and background swaps. * Choose **Adobe Photoshop** if you need high-precision edits where lighting and textures must match perfectly. * Use **Topaz Photo AI** if your photo is pixelated or blurry and needs fixing rather than changing.

                      How sources were used was not recorded.

                      Adobe Firefly · Canva
                      Read answer 4 · 18:38 UTC

                      The best AI tool for editing existing photos depends on what kind of edits you need to make. ### 1. Best Overall & Most Powerful: **Adobe Photoshop (with Firefly / Generative Fill)** * **Best for:** Seamlessly adding, removing, or replacing objects, expanding canvas borders (outpainting), and complex multi-layer editing. * **Why it stands out:** Adobe’s **Generative Fill** (powered by Firefly) is the industry standard for realistic photo edits. You can highlight any area of a photo and type a prompt to insert realistic objects, swap backgrounds, or remove unwanted distractions while perfectly matching lighting and shadows. * *Alternative:* If you don't need full desktop software, **Adobe Firefly on the web** offers quick generative edits for free or low cost. ### 2. Best for Fixing Image Quality (Blur, Noise & Upscaling): **Topaz Photo AI** * **Best for:** Restoring old, blurry, noisy, or low-resolution images. * **Why it stands out:** Topaz specializes in technical image repair. Instead of generating new objects, it focuses on sharpening out-of-focus faces, removing high-ISO digital noise, and upscaling low-res photos without making them look fake or plastic. ### 3. Best for Quick Content & Social Media: **Canva (Magic Studio)** * **Best for:** Quick edits, background swaps, and creating marketing materials or social posts. * **Why it stands out:** Canva’s **Magic Edit** and **Magic Eraser** tools make photo editing drag-and-drop simple. You brush over an object to replace it (e.g., change a shirt color) or erase clutter with a single click—no technical skill required. ### 4. Best for Product Photography & E-Commerce: **Photoroom** * **Best for:** Online sellers, marketplace listings, and studio-style product shots. * **Why it stands out:** Photoroom automatically isolates products, erases messy backgrounds, and generates realistic AI-rendered backdrops (like marble tables or sunlit rooms) with accurate realistic shadows. ### 5. Best Free Mobile App: **Google Photos (Magic Editor)** * **Best for:** Everyday smartphone photo cleanup (iOS & Android). * **Why it stands out:** Built into Google Photos, **Magic Editor** allows you to erase photo bombers, move subjects around in the frame, and adjust lighting (like relighting a sunset) straight from your phone for free. --- ### Summary Recommendation: * Go with **Adobe Photoshop / Firefly** if you want seamless generative changes and professional control. * Use **Canva** if you want fast, easy edits for web or social media. * Pick **Topaz Photo AI** if your primary goal is fixing blurry, noisy, or low-quality shots.

                      How sources were used was not recorded.

                      Canva
                      Read answer 5 · 18:38 UTC

                      There is no single "best" AI tool for editing existing photos—it depends on whether you want to alter elements inside the photo, restore photo quality, or swap out backgrounds. ### **1. Adobe Photoshop (Generative Fill / Firefly)** * **Best for:** Precision editing, adding/removing subjects, and expanding photo frames. * **Why buy it:** Photoshop remains the gold standard for editing existing images. Using Adobe Firefly, its **Generative Fill** and **Generative Expand** let you highlight any part of a photo to swap objects, change clothing, erase distractions, or extend edges while matching the original lighting and shadows seamlessly. * **Pricing:** Paid subscription (starts around $10–$23/month). --- ### **2. Topaz Photo AI** * **Best for:** Image restoration, fixing blur, removing noise, and upscaling low-res photos. * **Why buy it:** If your goal isn't changing the content of the photo but fixing quality issues (pixelation, low resolution, camera shake, grain), Topaz is unmatched. It analyzes existing details to intelligently sharpen focus and enhance textures without making the photo look artificial. * **Pricing:** One-time license (around $199). --- ### **3. Luminar Neo** * **Best for:** Photographers wanting automated portrait, landscape, and lighting edits. * **Why buy it:** Luminar uses AI to automate complex editing tasks like sky replacement, portrait retouching (smoothing skin, brightening eyes), subject relighting, and atmosphere adjustments without requiring complex selection masking. * **Pricing:** Monthly/annual subscription or one-time license option. --- ### **4. Canva (Magic Studio)** * **Best for:** Social media creators, quick edits, and graphic design integration. * **Why buy it:** Canva's AI tools (**Magic Eraser**, **Magic Edit**, and **Magic Grab**) make point-and-click editing simple. You can click an object in your photo to resize it, isolate subjects from the background, or erase unwanted items using plain-text prompts. * **Pricing:** Free basic tier; Pro starts at $15/month. --- ### **5. Photoroom** * **Best for:** Product photos and e-commerce seller edits. * **Why buy it:** If you sell online or need professional product shots, Photoroom automatically cuts out subjects from existing photos, generates studio-quality backgrounds, and places realistic shadows underneath products. * **Pricing:** Free basic tier; Pro plan available for high-res exports and batch processing. --- ### **6. Google Photos (Magic Editor)** * **Best for:** Quick, free edits directly on your phone. * **Why buy it:** For casual smartphone editing, Google Photos offers built-in AI tools like **Magic Eraser**, **Photo Unblur**, and **Magic Editor**. You can move subjects around the frame, change the color of the sky, or erase background objects right from your device. * **Pricing:** Free on iOS and Android (with expanded features for Google One subscribers). --- ### **Summary Recommendation** * **For complete creative control and heavy edits:** Choose **Adobe Photoshop**. * **For making blurry or grainy photos look crisp:** Choose **Topaz Photo AI**. * **For quick, easy web/social edits:** Choose **Canva** or **Google Photos**.

                      How sources were used was not recorded.

                      Perplexity 5 recorded answers
                      Imagen
                      Read answer 1 · 18:38 UTC

                      **Adobe Photoshop** is the best all-around choice if you want precise control: its Generative Fill can add, remove, or replace parts of a photo, and edits stay on separate layers so you can refine or undo them. For quick, conversational edits without learning a full editor, try **Google Gemini**: upload a photo and describe the change you want. It’s simpler, but offers less hands-on control. **Quick pick:** Photoshop for serious or detailed editing; Gemini for easy prompt-based changes.

                      How sources were used was not recorded.

                      Imagen
                      Read answer 2 · 18:38 UTC

                      **Adobe Photoshop** is the best all-around choice for editing existing photos: you can select a specific area, add or remove objects, extend the frame, and keep the original image editable in layers. Its AI tools give you more precise control than a simple prompt-only editor. If you want something easier and more conversational, try **Google Gemini’s image editor**—describe the change you want and iterate, with less manual selection. **Bottom line:** choose Photoshop for control and polished results; Gemini for quick, casual edits.

                      How sources were used was not recorded.

                      Canva
                      Read answer 3 · 18:38 UTC

                      **Adobe Photoshop is the best all-around choice** for editing existing photos, especially if you want precise control. Its Generative Fill lets you select an area and add, remove, or replace content while keeping the edit on a separate layer—handy for refining results later. If you want something simpler, **Canva** is easier for quick edits. For **product photos and backgrounds**, try **Photoroom**; for **portrait or landscape enhancements**, consider **Luminar Neo**.

                      How sources were used was not recorded.

                      Canva
                      Read answer 4 · 18:39 UTC

                      **Adobe Photoshop** is the best all-around choice for editing existing photos—especially if you want precise control. Its Generative Fill can add or remove content from selected areas, and its edits stay on separate layers so you can adjust them without changing the original. For quick, easy edits on your phone, try **Google Photos**: Magic Editor can move, resize, or remove objects and adjust backgrounds. **Canva** is a good fit if you also want to turn the edited photo into a design or social post. **Short version:** Photoshop for control and polished results; Google Photos for convenience.

                      How sources were used was not recorded.

                      Canva
                      Read answer 5 · 18:38 UTC

                      **Adobe Photoshop** is the best all-around choice if you want control: its selection tools, layers, and Generative Fill make it easier to remove, add, or replace parts of an existing photo while refining the result. For a quicker, simpler option, try **Google Photos** on your phone for everyday fixes like removing distractions or moving objects. **Canva** is handy if you’re also making social posts or designs, though some AI editing features require Pro. **Quick pick:** Photoshop for precision; Google Photos for easy mobile edits.

                      How sources were used was not recorded.

                      q13

                      What is the best open source AI image generator? #

                      Named first most often: Flux (25 of 30 answers with these filters).

                      30 recorded attempts with these filters.

                      Read full answers to this question

                      ChatGPT 5 recorded answers
                      Flux · Qwen-Image
                      Qwen-Image · Flux · Ideogram
                      Flux · Ideogram
                      Z-Image · Flux
                      Flux · Qwen-Image
                      Claude 5 recorded answers
                      Qwen-Image · Flux · Z-Image · Stable Diffusion
                      Qwen-Image · Flux · Z-Image · Stable Diffusion
                      Flux · Ideogram · Qwen-Image · Z-Image · Stable Diffusion
                      Flux · Stable Diffusion
                      Flux · Qwen-Image · Stable Diffusion
                      Claude Code (local) 5 recorded answers
                      Flux · Stable Diffusion
                      Flux · Qwen-Image · HunyuanImage · Z-Image · Sana
                      Flux · Qwen-Image · Z-Image · Stable Diffusion · HunyuanImage
                      Flux · Qwen-Image · Z-Image · HunyuanImage · Stable Diffusion · Sana
                      Flux · Stable Diffusion
                      Codex (local) 5 recorded answers
                      Flux
                      Flux
                      Flux
                      Flux
                      Flux
                      Gemini 5 recorded answers
                      Flux · Stable Diffusion · Z-Image
                      Flux · Stable Diffusion
                      Flux · Stable Diffusion · Ideogram · Qwen-Image · HunyuanImage
                      Flux · Stable Diffusion
                      Flux · Stable Diffusion · Qwen-Image
                      Perplexity 5 recorded answers
                      Flux
                      Flux · Stable Diffusion
                      Flux · Stable Diffusion
                      Flux · Qwen-Image · Stable Diffusion
                      Qwen-Image · Z-Image

                      q14

                      Which AI image generator is safest for licensing and copyright? #

                      Named first most often: Adobe Firefly (30 of 30 answers with these filters).

                      30 recorded attempts with these filters.

                      Read full answers to this question

                      ChatGPT 5 recorded answers
                      Adobe Firefly
                      Adobe Firefly
                      Adobe Firefly
                      Adobe Firefly
                      Adobe Firefly
                      Claude 5 recorded answers
                      Adobe Firefly
                      Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · Stable Diffusion
                      Adobe Firefly · Ideogram · Midjourney · Stable Diffusion
                      Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · Stable Diffusion
                      Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · Stable Diffusion
                      Claude Code (local) 5 recorded answers
                      Adobe Firefly · Canva · Midjourney · Stable Diffusion
                      Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · Stable Diffusion
                      Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · Stable Diffusion
                      Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · Stable Diffusion
                      Adobe Firefly · Imagen · Midjourney · Stable Diffusion
                      Codex (local) 5 recorded answers
                      Adobe Firefly
                      Adobe Firefly
                      Adobe Firefly
                      Adobe Firefly
                      Adobe Firefly
                      Gemini 5 recorded answers
                      Adobe Firefly
                      Adobe Firefly · Midjourney
                      Adobe Firefly
                      Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · DALL-E · Imagen
                      Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · Stable Diffusion
                      Perplexity 5 recorded answers
                      Adobe Firefly
                      Adobe Firefly
                      Adobe Firefly
                      Adobe Firefly
                      Adobe Firefly

                      q15

                      What AI image generator should a small business use? #

                      Named first most often: Canva (26 of 30 answers with these filters).

                      30 recorded attempts with these filters.

                      Read full answers to this question

                      ChatGPT 5 recorded answers
                      Canva · DALL-E · Adobe Firefly · Midjourney
                      Canva · Adobe Firefly
                      Canva · Adobe Firefly · Midjourney
                      Canva · Adobe Firefly · Ideogram
                      Canva · DALL-E · Adobe Firefly · Midjourney
                      Claude 5 recorded answers
                      Canva · Adobe Firefly · Imagen · Midjourney
                      Canva · Adobe Firefly · Ideogram · Imagen
                      Canva · Adobe Firefly · Ideogram · Imagen · Midjourney
                      Canva · Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · Imagen · Ideogram
                      Canva · Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · Imagen
                      Claude Code (local) 5 recorded answers
                      Adobe Firefly · Canva · Midjourney · Ideogram
                      Adobe Firefly · Canva · Midjourney · Imagen · Ideogram
                      Adobe Firefly · Canva · Midjourney · Imagen · Ideogram
                      Canva · Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · Imagen · Ideogram
                      Adobe Firefly · Canva · Midjourney · Imagen · Ideogram
                      Codex (local) 5 recorded answers
                      Canva · Adobe Firefly
                      Canva · Adobe Firefly
                      Canva · Adobe Firefly
                      Canva · Adobe Firefly
                      Canva · DALL-E · Adobe Firefly
                      Gemini 5 recorded answers
                      Canva · Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · Ideogram
                      Canva · Adobe Firefly · Ideogram · Midjourney
                      Canva · Adobe Firefly · Ideogram · Midjourney
                      Canva · Adobe Firefly · Ideogram · Midjourney
                      Canva · Adobe Firefly · Midjourney · Ideogram
                      Perplexity 5 recorded answers
                      Canva · Adobe Firefly
                      Canva · Adobe Firefly
                      Canva · Adobe Firefly
                      Canva · Adobe Firefly
                      Canva · Adobe Firefly · Midjourney